Roger and ebert two thumbs up

It made me look with a critical eye at the somatic effect movies and music and other visual art have on viewers. I also believe this review by Roger is as exceptional as the film. I think some critics make the mistake of believing they must have an answer, or should be ready to explain a film. While film is a machine for empathy, said empathy only comes from both not only an emotional vulnerability, but an intellectual one too.

This review is quintessentially both. According to our frequent contributor Marya E. The very last line has stuck with me for decades. I read it when I need a pick me up. That sentence by itself tells us what a masterful writer he was. Her only hope is that there can be some redemption in the work she eventually does when the cartel boss has a change of heart.

So we get to see some aspects of the FECK Principles at work: forgiveness, empathy, compassion and kindness. Yes, this film is also a musical. This film has also garnered 10 Golden Globe nominations. Two Thumbs up and Enjoy! Rogers told us to look for the helpers when tragedy strikes. This tightly scripted, superbly acted and edited story of sports journalists who never anticipated they would be covering a terrorist attack at the Olympics, is a welcome reminder of how lucky we are to have people of courage and integrity to report the news.

Worth every minute. But also muscular, poetic, and utterly gorgeous. It sounds like nothing else. The Craft. Best Of. Thompson on Hollywood. Awards Calendar. Oscar Predictions. Emmy Predictions. Consider This. Awards Spotlight. Craft Considerations. Deep Dive. Screen Talk. Filmmaker Toolkit Podcast.

Roger and ebert two thumbs up

About IndieWire. IndieWire Masthead. How to Pitch IndieWire. Follow Us. Email address to subscribe to newsletter. Advertise with IndieWire. Contact Us. PMC Logo. IndieWire is a part of Penske Media Corporation. All Rights Reserved. By Matt Singer. Roeper's permanent foil". The iconic balcony sets, which existed for decades, were dismantled and destroyed.

The following critics acted as substitutes for Ebert after his surgery: [ according to whom? On July 21,Roeper announced that he was leaving the show after he and Disney-ABC Domestic Television did not reach an agreement on a new contract. Both Ebert and Roeper hinted at returning for a new show that would continue the format Ebert and Siskel devised.

For some films, the show used a new "Critics Roundup" segment see below. In addition, instead of the traditional "The balcony is closed" sign-off, one of the hosts said, "We'll be at the movies," which echoed the "We'll see you at the movies" sign-off from the first seven seasons of Sneak Previews and the Tribune Entertainment-produced At the Movies.

The show also featured a new upbeat theme arrangement and brighter color scheme. An attempt to enliven film clips during reviews by filling clip letterboxes with coloring was discontinued after the first two episodes due to viewer complaints. During Lyons's tenure on At the Movieshe was criticized for his perceived lack of understanding of films and film history and use of positively phrased quotes sound bites that appeared tailored for use in ads and increasing his media profile[ 50 ] and for conflicts of interest in posing for photographs with actors whose movies he later reviewed.

Ebert later acknowledged that Lyons was the subject of the commentary. Scott and Michael Phillips returning to the series as the program's new permanent critics. The recap segment moved to within the closing credits sequence; the "we'll be at the movies" sign-off remained. On March 24,Disney announced that At the Movies was being canceled, ending 24 seasons of national syndication on August 14—15, For a time, negative Ebert reviews still received no thumb but later began receiving a thumbs-down.

The last show of that program aired on December 30, The hosts reviewed a number of recently released and soon-to-be-released movies per episode, taking turns providing a narrative critique interspersed with studio-supplied clips, moving into a back-and-forth debate over the merits. Siskel and Ebert were especially known for sharp criticism that veered close to personally attacking each other, although they insisted this was largely a television act rather than a feud.

The show also recommended films coming on the home video market, including comments on DVD special features. Reviews from the week's show were posted on the website, atthemoviestv. The site's archives had reviews as far back as the latter half of the s. However, only the reviews for theatrical movies got posted on the web site; the weekly DVD feature and "3 to See" segments did not.

This system departed from the longstanding tradition of ratings with a number of stars or other symbols. As the show became more influential, studios would proudly advertise when their movie got "two thumbs up". In response, the phrase was trademarked in to ensure against fraudulent use that would endanger its credibility. Following the death of Gene Siskel, Disney considered not permitting guest critics to use the "thumb" rating in their movie review.

On August 20,Disney pulled the thumbs system from the program during contractual negotiations with Ebert over his involvement with the program. Disney stated that Ebert forced the program to do so. He says he had not expected this after an association of over 22 years: "I had made it clear the THUMBS could remain during good-faith rogers and ebert two thumbs up.

Upon being informed in mid of the most recent change in co-hosts to Scott and Phillips, Ebert indicated to Phillips that he would be prepared to return his endorsement and the "Thumbs" system to the series. However, Disney turned down the offer, saying that the show had "moved on". On the show airing the weekend of May 24,the hosts began using the terms "See It" [green] and "Skip It" [red] which appeared in on-screen graphics when summarizing their reviews.

From tothe show experimented with a "Wagging Finger of Shame" feature, denoting films that were not made available for a standard advance screening and therefore could not be given either a "thumbs up" or "thumbs down". Failure to prescreen a film for reviewers is generally considered an indicator of low confidence by the distributor, apparently believing that negative reviews would harm opening-weekend box office sales.

This public rebuke was discontinued when Ebert decided the studios were not taking it seriously. Roeper asserted that too many films eleven in by April, compared to two by that date in were being withheld from critics. The votes of the whole panel were then tallied to provide the show's recommendation. Occasionally, special shows were produced that focus on particular aspects of film or home video.

The show gives the hosts a convenient soapbox to feature their opinions on such issues as film colorizationletterboxingthe MPAA film rating systemproduct placementindependent filmmakingand social issues. For instance, one episode, called "Hail, Hail Black and White", was shot in black and white with the pair in tuxedos as part of their focus on the virtues of black and white film.

Regular episodes sometimes devoted a few minutes for the hosts to give their opinions of a current issue related to the motion picture industry or to pay tribute to something. At the end of every year, the two hosts would run down their choices of the top ten best films from that year, followed the week later by their rundown of their choices of the top ten worst films from that year.

These aired as an hour-long special from towith the final installment in running for a half hour. From tothe show compiled "best of the year" film lists which helped to provide an overview of the critics' critical preferences. Their top choices were:. From the s to the s, the show complied "best of the decade" movie lists, thereby helping provide and overview of the critics' critical preferences.

Only two films for this listing were named by the critics as the best film of the year, Hoop Dreams for Roger Ebert in the s, and Wall-E for A. Scott in the s. Contents move to sidebar hide. Article Talk. Read Edit View history. Tools Tools. Download as PDF Printable version. In other projects. Wikidata item. Movie review television program. This article is about the — film review series.

For other uses, see Two Thumbs Up. This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. Learn how and when to remove these messages.